```htmlQuality of Earnings Report: Starbucks Corporation

Quality of Earnings Report

Starbucks Corporation (NASDAQ: SBUX)

Can Starbucks Brew Up a Turnaround?

Date of Report: June 17, 2025

Period Under Review: Fiscal Years 2021, 2022, 2023 (and recent trends)

Executive Summary

This Quality of Earnings (QoE) report provides an analysis of Starbucks Corporation's ("Starbucks" or "the Company") financial performance, business model, and growth trajectory, with a focus on its ability to navigate current challenges and execute a successful turnaround. The analysis covers fiscal years 2021, 2022, and 2023, along with qualitative insights into more recent developments.

Starbucks has demonstrated revenue growth over the analyzed period, recovering from pandemic-related disruptions. However, profitability has faced pressures from inflation, increased labor costs, and significant investments related to its "Reinvention Plan." Normalized EBITDA calculations suggest underlying operational strength, but these adjustments, primarily for restructuring and investment costs, must be carefully considered for their future impact.

The Company's core business model remains robust, leveraging a strong brand and global presence. Scalability is proven, but sustainability of margins is contingent on successful execution of turnaround initiatives, particularly improving store efficiency, managing labor relations, and adapting to evolving consumer preferences. Key risks include intense competition, ongoing labor activism, geopolitical uncertainties impacting international markets (especially China), and potential slowdowns in consumer discretionary spending.

While the "Reinvention Plan" holds promise for long-term growth and efficiency, its execution and financial impact require close monitoring. The quality of recent earnings is impacted by these strategic investments. A successful turnaround hinges on Starbucks' ability to translate these investments into sustainable improvements in customer experience, operational efficiency, and ultimately, enhanced profitability and shareholder value.

1. Company Overview

Starbucks Corporation is the premier roaster, marketer, and retailer of specialty coffee in the world, operating in approximately 86 markets. The Company operates through two main segments: North America and International. It sells coffee and other beverages, complementary food items, and packaged goods through company-operated stores, licensed stores, and consumer-packaged goods (CPG) channels.

2. Turnaround Context & Strategic Initiatives

In recent years, Starbucks has faced several headwinds, including:

• Rising Labor Costs and Unionization Efforts: Increased wages and benefits, alongside a unionization drive in the U.S., have put pressure on operating expenses and labor relations.
• Inflationary Pressures: Higher costs for raw materials (coffee, dairy, food ingredients) and supply chain disruptions have impacted cost of goods sold.
• Changing Consumer Behavior: Post-pandemic shifts in work patterns and increased demand for convenience (mobile orders, drive-thrus) have strained existing store operations and layouts.
• Competition: Intense competition from other coffee chains, independent cafes, and at-home coffee solutions.
• International Market Volatility: Performance in key international markets, particularly China, has faced volatility due to economic conditions and geopolitical factors.

In response, Starbucks launched its comprehensive "Reinvention Plan" in late 2022, focusing on:

• Elevating the Partner (Employee) Experience: Investments in wages, training, and store manager support.
• Enhancing the Customer Experience: Store modernization, equipment upgrades to improve speed and efficiency (e.g., Siren System), and personalized digital offerings.
• Reimagining Stores: Optimizing store formats for mobile orders, delivery, and drive-thru.
• Strengthening Digital Capabilities: Leveraging its Starbucks Rewards program and mobile app.
• Expanding Global Reach: Continued focus on international growth, particularly in China and other emerging markets.

The success of these initiatives is critical for Starbucks to "brew up a turnaround" and achieve sustainable, profitable growth.

3. Financial Performance Analysis

3.1. Key Financial Highlights (Fiscal Years)

Starbucks' fiscal year ends on the Sunday closest to September 30th.

Source: Starbucks SEC Filings (10-K). Note: FY2021 benefited from divestitures and lower restructuring. FY2022 saw significant investment impacts. FY2023 shows recovery and continued investment.

3.2. Normalized EBITDA Calculation (Illustrative)

To assess underlying operational profitability, we calculate an illustrative Normalized EBITDA. Actual QoE adjustments would involve a detailed review of non-recurring items.

<sup>1</sup>Note: "Reinvention Plan" costs are substantial and ongoing; classifying portions as non-recurring requires careful judgment. Some are true investments expected to yield future returns. For this illustration, a portion is added back to show potential underlying earnings power before these specific strategic outlays. A detailed QoE would scrutinize these costs extensively.

3.3. Revenue Recognition and Cost Structures

Revenue Recognition: Starbucks primarily recognizes revenue at the point of sale for company-operated stores. For licensed stores, revenue includes royalties and license fees. CPG revenue is recognized when products are shipped and control is transferred. Revenue recognition policies appear consistent and appropriate under ASC 606.

Cost Structure:

• Cost of Sales: Primarily food, beverage, and packaging costs. Subject to commodity price volatility. Occupancy costs are also significant.
• Store Operating Expenses: Largest component is labor (wages, benefits), followed by other store-level costs. This area is under pressure from wage inflation and investments.
• General & Administrative: Corporate overhead.

Recent trends show gross margins have been relatively stable but slightly compressed, while operating margins have seen more pressure due to increased store operating expenses and strategic investments.

3.4. Margin Sustainability

Margin sustainability is a key question for Starbucks. Strengths: Strong brand loyalty allows for some pricing power. Global scale provides procurement advantages. Risks: Ongoing wage pressures, commodity inflation, and the need for continuous investment in store modernization and technology could continue to pressure margins. The success of the "Reinvention Plan" in driving operational leverage (e.g., improved throughput from new equipment reducing labor hours per transaction) is crucial. Competitive pressures may limit the extent of price increases.

4. Business Model Assessment

4.1. Core Revenue Streams & Cost Drivers

• Company-Operated Stores: Primary revenue driver, providing direct control over brand experience and quality. Highest margin potential but also highest operating cost burden.
• Licensed Stores: Capital-light model for expansion, generating royalties and product sales. Lower margin percentage but high ROI.
• Channel Development (CPG): Sales of packaged coffee, tea, and ready-to-drink beverages through grocery stores and other retail outlets. Leverages brand into broader consumer reach.

Key Cost Drivers: Green coffee bean prices, dairy costs, labor (wages, benefits, training), rent for store locations, marketing and G&A expenses.

4.2. Scalability and Sustainability

Starbucks' business model is inherently scalable, as demonstrated by its global expansion. The licensed store model facilitates rapid, capital-efficient growth. However, the sustainability of its current operating model in high-cost labor markets is being tested. The "Reinvention Plan" aims to address this by improving efficiency and partner engagement.

Sustainability in a broader ESG sense is also critical. Starbucks has made commitments regarding ethical sourcing, waste reduction, and energy efficiency, which carry associated costs but also enhance brand reputation.

4.3. Key Operational Risks and Dependencies

• Labor Relations: Ongoing unionization efforts and the need to attract/retain talent in a competitive labor market.
• Supply Chain Disruptions: Reliance on global supply chains for coffee beans and other inputs makes it vulnerable to geopolitical events, climate change, and logistical challenges.
• Competition: From global chains (e.g., McDonald's McCafe, Dunkin') to local specialty coffee shops and at-home consumption trends.
• Consumer Preferences: Shifting tastes, health consciousness, and demand for convenience require continuous innovation and adaptation.
• Economic Conditions: Discretionary spending on premium coffee can be impacted by economic downturns.
• Geopolitical Risks: Exposure to international markets, especially China, carries political and economic instability risks.
• Technology & Digital: Heavy reliance on its mobile app and rewards program. Any disruptions or failure to innovate could impact customer engagement and sales.

5. Growth Trajectory Evaluation

5.1. Historical Growth Rates and Drivers

Starbucks has a long history of strong growth, primarily driven by:

• Store Expansion: Aggressive new store openings, both company-operated and licensed, globally.
• Comparable Store Sales Growth: Driven by increased traffic and average ticket value, menu innovation, and strong customer loyalty programs.
• International Expansion: Particularly in China and other Asia-Pacific markets.
• Channel Development: Growth in CPG and ready-to-drink segments.

Revenue grew from $29.1B in FY2021 to $36.0B in FY2023, a CAGR of approximately 11.2%. However, this period includes recovery from pandemic lows. More recent quarterly results (into FY2024, not detailed in tables here) have shown moderating growth in some areas, highlighting the challenges the company faces.

5.2. Project Future Growth Potential

Future growth is expected to be driven by:

• Continued International Expansion: Focus on underpenetrated markets and further growth in China despite recent slowdowns.
• "Reinvention Plan" Payoffs: Improved store efficiency, enhanced customer experience, and partner productivity leading to higher comparable store sales.
• Digital Innovation: Further leveraging the Starbucks Rewards program, personalization, and mobile ordering/delivery capabilities.
• Menu Innovation: Introduction of new beverages and food items catering to evolving tastes.
• Format Diversification: More drive-thrus, smaller footprint stores, and delivery-focused outlets.

Management has provided long-term growth targets, but achieving these will depend on successful execution and navigating the aforementioned risks. Analysts project mid-to-high single-digit revenue growth in the coming years, contingent on a successful turnaround.

5.3. Benchmarking Performance (Brief)

Compared to industry peers in the quick-service restaurant (QSR) and coffee segments, Starbucks generally commands premium pricing and historically strong comparable store sales growth. However, its operating margins have recently lagged some efficient QSR operators due to higher labor intensity and investment cycles. Its digital and loyalty programs are often considered best-in-class. A full benchmarking would compare metrics against companies like McDonald's, Yum! Brands, Restaurant Brands International, and other specialty coffee players.

6. Key Findings, Strengths & Potential Red Flags

Summary of Findings

Strengths:

• Powerful Global Brand: Significant brand equity and customer loyalty.
• Extensive Global Reach: Diversified geographic footprint.
• Strong Digital Platform: Leading loyalty program and mobile app drive engagement and sales.
• Proven Ability to Innovate: Continuous menu and concept evolution.
• Strategic "Reinvention Plan": Proactive approach to addressing current challenges with substantial investment.

Risks and Areas for Further Due Diligence:

• Margin Pressure: Ongoing impact of inflation, labor costs, and investments on profitability. Sustainability of margins post-investment phase is key.
• Execution Risk of "Reinvention Plan": The plan is ambitious and costly; successful execution and achieving projected ROI are critical. Monitoring specific KPIs related to store efficiency and customer satisfaction post-implementation is vital.
• Labor Relations and Costs: Unionization efforts and rising wage/benefit expectations continue to be a significant factor.
• Slowing Growth in Key Markets: Recent performance in North America and China has shown some deceleration, requiring careful monitoring of consumer trends and competitive responses.
• Dependency on China Market: While a growth driver, this market also presents significant geopolitical and economic volatility.
• Quality of Earnings Adjustments: Significant restructuring and investment costs impact reported earnings. The recurring nature vs. truly one-time nature of these costs needs scrutiny for valuation purposes.

Overall Assessment:

Starbucks is at a pivotal juncture. The company possesses fundamental strengths that provide a solid foundation for a turnaround. The quality of its earnings in the short-to-medium term will likely continue to be influenced by strategic investments. The long-term success of its "Reinvention Plan" will determine if Starbucks can re-accelerate profitable growth and "brew up" a sustained positive trajectory. Stakeholders should closely monitor execution progress, margin trends, and comparable store sales growth in key markets. Further due diligence should focus on the specific returns generated from the "Reinvention Plan" investments and the normalization of operating expenses post-investment cycle.

7. Charts and Tables

7.1. Financial Trends (FY2021-FY2023)

8. Citations and Sources

The financial data and qualitative information presented in this report are based on publicly available information, including but not limited to:

• Starbucks Corporation SEC Filings (Annual Reports on Form 10-K for fiscal years 2023, 2022, 2021). These can typically be found on the SEC's EDGAR database or Starbucks' Investor Relations website.
  • Example: Starbucks Investor Relations - SEC Filings (Link is illustrative of where such documents are found)
• Starbucks Corporation Investor Relations website, including press releases, investor presentations, and earnings call transcripts.
  • Example: Starbucks Investor Relations
• Reputable financial news outlets and industry publications for qualitative analysis and context regarding market trends, strategic initiatives, and challenges (e.g., The Wall Street Journal, Bloomberg, Reuters, Financial Times).

Disclaimer: This report is for illustrative and informational purposes only, based on publicly available data and standard QoE analysis principles. It does not constitute financial advice or an exhaustive due diligence investigation. Specific figures for QoE adjustments are illustrative and would require a detailed, non-public data review in a formal engagement. The "current date" of June 17, 2025, is noted, but the primary financial data reflects the latest full audited fiscal years (ending October 2023) and general trends discussed publicly up to early/mid-2024. A live QoE would incorporate all subsequent interim financials and developments.

Quality of Earnings Analysis - Starbucks Corporation - June 17, 2025

```